Star Atlas ports a paper book to the iPhone. Other than placing a weightless, bulkless book in your pocket, it essentially bypasses all the advantages of computerization. You can not pan the entire sky, can not tap an object and have its information appear, can not have the app show which objects are currently visible in your location (or will be at a given hour).
It is impossible to zoom smoothly, because the way the objects change size creates the illusion of reversing the intended zoom. The centering often changes when zooming out, whenever the wider zoom conflicts with the edge of the current map. This is the biggest problem designing an app as separate maps, rather than as a continuous planetarium-- especially with the additional misfeature of dimmer objects often hiding upon zooming out to see their location.
There is no Find command, so objects can only be found in alphabetical lists, but only if one already knows their complex names.
I bought the app for its list of double stars, but without being able to find and sort which stars are sufficiently bright to be seen from my location at this hour, it has been no use to me. One might argue that I am too inexperienced to know how to use the app, to which Id counter that if the app isnt doing much of the work, we may as well all return to carrying and using paper books.
Despite its faults, the app is well crafted for being what it is. I oddly admire it. Experienced paper-chart traditionalists might like its familiarity. The overall design likely fares better with the authors Moon Map Pro when compared with competing moon apps, where higher resolution images give separate maps an edge.
Five changes would radically enhance this app:
(1) Add a Find command.
(2) Allow changing maps by hard dragging the edge of the current map away from the edge of the screen. The next map would then slide into place. Lots of PDF readers work this way when changing pages. It would allow a not-too-awkward ability to pan the sky.
(3) Isolate panning from zooming. When zooming, keep a centered object centered, even if that means showing an empty background beyond the edge of the map.
(4) Objects selected from a list should be highlit, and should remain visible regardless of changes in zoom. Dimmer objects vanish from the map when zooming out to determine where they are in the sky!
(5) The option for red night vision in the lists should be eliminated, in favor of layouts based on light text on black backgrounds. These, like the maps, would be truly visible at night.